Portraits: Here as elsewhere, we have reason to revolt!

[en traduction – bientôt en français]

ici comme ailleurs... david (Imagerie d'un printemps érable)

Masses & Médias 2013, Montréal,

Le montage des 26 bannières est terminé. The installation of the 26 banners is complete. La Société des arts technologique, Montréal – March 12 mars 2013 – photo: David Widgington.

On Wednesday, March 13 during the Masses & Médias 2013 event, I decided to do a portrait series of photographs with the wall of banners on exhibit as a backdrop. The idea is not original. In fact it’s a ripoff. While hanging more banners from the 13-foot ceiling atop a mobile staircase, two guys walked into La SAT. One of them ran to the wall of banners and stared for a while before standing in front of the one that read “Ici comme ailleurs on a raison de se révolter”. He lifted his left fist into the air, mimicking the banner’s iconography and asked his friend to take a photo. “I’m going to send it out on Twitter,” he shouted back at me as he left. The guy came and went so fast, I didn’t get the chance to ask him about his motivation. I decided to reproduce the initiative at the event.

I invited visitors at the exhibit to stand in front of the same banner with their clenched fist raised to emulate what I had witnessed earlier. No other instructions were given, other than to stand on the ‘X’ taped to the floor. My motivation was to encourage people to interact with the banner and its message in a context other than a street protest and to capture their stance as a new cultural artefact: the photograph. I emailed each portrait to the person(s) portrayed, so they may add it to their personal “shoebox collections” as mediated memories. José van Dijck writes:

“Mediated memories are the activities and objects we produce and appropriate by means of media technologies, for creating and re-creating a sense of past, present, and future of ourselves in relation to others.” — p.21 (1)

The portraits brought the banner from the past into the present as new cultural production. After they are distributed then shared, they have the potential to inspire actions in the future. At least that is my objective.

ici comme ailleurs on a raison de se révolter.

“Here as elsewhere we have reason to revolt.” bannière: la CLASSE. Rue Berri coin de Maisonneuve, Montréal – July 22 juillet 2013. photo: David Widgington

Each portrait is centred around a banner that was originally used on the streets during protest. At the March 13 exhibit, the banner was de-contextualized from its intended use of leading a contingent during a protest. That night, a group of Cégep students entered the exhibit space and were offended by the display of protest banners. Some of them left, emotionally shaken by the exhibit, one of them apparently in tears. Two of the students stayed behind to seek me out and convey their indignation. “How can you display these banners that are made for the street, some of which I participated in their creation, in a gallery or museum setting, as though the protests were finished!?” I remember pointing to the ‘Mères en colère et solidaires’ banner and telling the students that the woman who takes care of this banner came up to me earlier in the evening to remind me that she needed the banner back by the weekend for a scheduled protest the following week. To the students, the word “archive” was associated with institutionalized memory, museums, capital ‘H’ history and dust. This exhibit was a ritual gathering, a media activism event.

If a demonstration is considered as a performance (one without a script but shaped by ritual) then, according to Victor Turner, activists carrying the banner within a demonstration are in the active “liminal” phase of oppositional performance. The preceding phase, in this context would, include the selection of fabric and paints, the review of potential slogans and the creation of the banner. This leisurely phase, according to Turner, “separates” the activist from the ritual of protest within a preparatory period of collaboration.(2) During the Masses & Médias event activists were in “reaggregation”: a “post-performance” phase marked by a debriefing “cooling down” period, a ritual celebration of past actions that invariably leads to future oppositional performance: a cyclical loop of collective self-renewal.

La bannière est réutilisée lors de la vigile silencieuse contre la brutalié. Banner reused as intended during vigil against police brutality - Montréal March 29 mars 2013. photo : Thien V.

La bannière est réutilisée lors de la vigile silencieuse contre les arrestations de masse sous le règlement municipale P-6. The banner is reused as originally intended during vigil against mass arrests under municipal by-law P-6. Rue Ste-Catherine coin Jeanne-Mance, Montréal – March 29 mars 2013. photo : Thien V.

Each portrait (re)mediates the banner within a new cultural object. Although the banner is the unifying feature of the portrait series, it is no longer the central signifier. The portraits now derive meaning not just from the banner’s claim, but also from each individual’s deliberate and expressive affiliation to that claim. The desire to participate in the portrait series is in itself an oppositional cultural act that will be reinforced when individuals share their portraits with others.

(re)Collected visual artefacts from the 2012 ‘maple spring’ from reserves of posters, banners and protest signs “can be considered markers of cultural agency; it is through these creative rerecordings and recollections that [oppositional] cultural heritage becomes established” (van Dijck p.25). Wendy Chun (p.164) writes that “memory must be held in order to keep it from moving or fading. Memory does not equal storage. While memory looks backward […] to store is to furnish, to build stock. Storage or stocks always looks forward to the future”(3).

This particular banner — because of the perennial nature of its message  — is a powerful source of both memory and stock. It seamlessly unites one protest movement to another and can associate one particularly vigorous period of opposition (like the printemps érable) with the next, due to its inclusiveness.

I suggest that the mashup, sampling and recirculation of visual artefacts stored in this archive will nurture oppositional consciousness provoked during the printemps érable and will affirm an oppositional cultural heritage that will thrive.


[vimeo http://vimeo.com/63412604 w=640&h=360]

musique : Chaotic Insurrection Ensemble

photos : Cédric Piette



(1) van Dijck, José (2007) Mediated Memories in the Digital Age. Stanford: Stanford University Press.

(2) Schechner, Richard (1986) “Preface: Victor Turner’s Last Adventure.” in The Anthropology of Performance by Victor Turner. New York : PAJ Publications, pp.7-20.

(3) Chun, Wendy Hui Kyong (2008) “The Enduring Ephemeral, or the Future is a Memory” in Critical Enquiry, No. 35, Autumn, pp. 148-171.

You may also like...

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.